Senate spoiler?

The race for Texas’ SD 25 should have been cut and dry: conservative (Donna Campbell) vs. not (Jeff Wentworth). But now that Elizabeth Ames Jones has joined the race, I don’t know what to expect.

If Jones succeeds at presenting herself as a “proven, prepared constitutional conservative,” she could split the vote with Donna Campbell, and we may as well hand the seat right back to Wentworth. But she lacks the name recognition both other candidates have, especially after Campbell’s high-profile fight with Lloyd Doggett in the last election, as well as the infectious energy, the “fire in her belly” that endears Campbell to her many supporters.

Any way you look at it, Jones is an establishment Republican. It’s more likely – at least, I hope – she’ll split the vote with Wentworth, allowing Campbell to take the win like she should have in 2010.

(Or it could have no effect whatsoever. After all, Jones barely had $300,000 for a national Senate campaign by the end of Q3.)

Jones certainly talks all the right talk. There are a few minor bills she authored or voted for in her time as a state legislator I could take issue with, but I haven’t found anything horrendously un-conservative with her record. If Jones was the only Wentworth alternative, I might have considered voting for her.

But this race-switching move makes me question her commitment. Does it lie with the conservative cause or with personal victory? Holding political office is a privilege, not an entitlement; shopping around for a winnable race rather than identifying one goal and working towards it is the epitome of what’s wrong with our political system. I can’t help but wonder whether her votes will be influenced by the same gamesmanship. In the words of a friend of mine in politics, “I keep giving the party establishment the benefit of the doubt, and they always seem to fall short.”

My support remains solidly with Campbell. Any self-proclaimed conservative who votes for Wentworth in the primary doesn’t understand the meaning of the word. Any conservative who votes for Jones risks allowing political gamesmanship to bog down our political system.

Donna Campbell will be a much-needed breath of fresh air. I have no doubt in my mind that she will always vote with her conscience, regardless of what is politically advantageous.

Here’s to a real conservative – not a politician – in 2012.

If you live in SD 25, expect to see me knocking on your door with a Donna Campbell push card some time soon.

More posts on the SD 25 race:

  • Earl Grey

    Political gamesmanship? Such as moving into the district a year before the race just so you can run? If anyone is just trying to get elected wherever they can it’s Campbell. I think you said it yourself, Jones has a conservative record you can’t really argue with. Campbell’s record on the other hand is just what you said, self-proclaimed, because it doesn’t exist. I think your name ID analysis is also pretty weak. Campbell doesn’t know anyone in SD 25 because she’s never lived there and no one payed close attention to the (not very close) Doggett race. Conversely, Jones is from SD 25, has been elected to Tx ledge by SD 25 and has been the railroad commissioner.

    At least we can both agree that Wentworth can’t be reelected. But I don’t buy your doomsday scenario when there is clearly going to be a runoff with the winner between Campbell or Jones getting the other’s supporters. Or we get both and then we win either way.

    • Katie Thompson

      I don’t believe I described a “doomsday scenario.” I merely expressed my opinion on which candidate I trust more to act correctly – infer what you will from the results of that.

      As for moving into the district, I don’t agree it qualifies as gamesmanship in this situation. Dr. Campbell saw a seat where there was no conservative challenger to a moderate incumbent and gave voters an alternative. Jones, on the other hand, doesn’t bring much of anything new to the race, and it’s hard to see how her switch wasn’t at least verging on gamesmanship, especially after dropping out of a race she couldn’t win.

  • Pingback: Texas Redistricting – Let the Judges Get a Hold of This Idea | Texas Report